2009 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Chris Anderson | RB | Troy University |
| Calin Archer | OL | Pittsburg State University |
| Chris Clay | RB | Western Alabama University |
| Adam Davis | DE | Kansas State University |
| Kendall Davis | DB | Pittsburg State University |
| Justin Green | OL | Kansas State University |
| William Grissom | DT | Pittsburg State University |
| Chase Hartman | OL | Kansas Wesleyan University |
| Gage McKinnis | WR | Kansas State University |
| Sam Norris | DB | Pittsburg State University |
| Matthew Pearson | S | Kansas State University |
| Michael Powell | OL | Kansas State University |
| Randy Salmon | DT | University of Louisville |
| Maurice Woodard | DB | Lincoln University |
| Darrel Zellars | DT | Tulsa University |
2008 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Eugene Kinlaw | DL | Troy University |
| Jacob Lattimer | LB | Iowa State |
| Nate Newland | OL | Troy University |
| Jasper Simmons | S | Missouri |
| Jamar Bass | OL | South Florida |
| Thatcher Starling | DE | Florida International |
| Jacob Miller | OL | Louisiana Tech |
| Clinton Stein | P | Oklahoma State |
| LaDarrian Page | RB | Emporia State |
| Vincent Harris | DB | Emporia State |
| Richard Spain | OL | Newberry College |
| Josh Goffigan | WR | Lincoln University |
| Jeremy Sifford | OL | Tarleton State |
| Eric Mateos | OL | Southwest Baptist U. |
| Galen Hagga | TE | Friends University |
| Dakotah Gettler | QB | Ottawa University |
2007 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Antwon Canady | LB | Louisville |
| Tariq Pauly | OL | Utah State |
| Chris Todd | QB | Auburn |
| Brandon Kush | DL | Central Arkansas |
| Dustin Heckroth | LB | Pittsburg State |
| Josh Fiscus | LB | Fort Hays State |
| Danny McEvoy | WR | Emporia State Univeristy |
| Bryant Yoder | OL | Southeastern Oklahoma St. |
2006 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| David Woods | RB | Northern Colorado |
2005 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Nehemiah Warrick | DB | Michigan State |
| Brian Roulhac | RB | Kansas |
| Chad Weaver | OL | Emporia State |
| Jared Doke | WR | Central Missouri State |
| Brandon Smith | DL | Ottawa University |
2004 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Dallas Browning | LB | Morningside |
| DeShawn Goldsmith | DB | Mid-America Nazarene |
| Wes Haines | WR | Bethel |
| Jed Henson | OL | Kansas State |
| Stephen Kelley | OL | Upper Iowa |
| Steven Mathias | LB | Kansas State |
| Cornelius Minnafield | DB | James Madison |
| Charles Morgan | DB | Fort Hays State |
| Josh Pinaire | DL | Oklahoma State University |
| John Racette | P | Panhandle State |
| Justin Rainey | DB | Middle Tennessee State |
| Kyle Roberts | WR | Sam Houston State |
| A.J. Wallace | DE | Southern Illinois |
| Willie Williams | DE | Kansas State |
2003 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Carlton Baker | LB | Memphis |
| David Bass | LB | Emporia State |
| Jermaine Collins | DE | Texas Southern |
| Lonnie Davis | DL | Memphis |
| Jamar Flournoy | DB | East Carolina |
| Todd Foster | LB | Kansas |
| Jason Froese | OL | Nebraska-Kearney |
| Emil Gibson | DL | Newberry College |
| Josh Hamilton | DL | Arkansas State |
| Marquis Johnson | WR | Texas Tech |
| Travontay King | WR | Mid-America Nazarene |
| Chris Link | LB | Kansas |
| Justin Mathias | DL | Tabor College |
| Logan Mize | LB | Southern Illinois |
| Austin Murphy | DE | Kansas State |
| LaDrew Murrell | WR | Mid-America Nazarene |
| David Sutton | DB | Tabor College |
| Shaun Teeter | LB | Fort Hays State |
| Scott Tilley | WR | Tabor College |
| Gary Trione | K | Kansas Wesleyan |
| Billy Waters | LB | Pittsburg State |
2002 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Justin Pond | QB | Arkansas Tech |
2001 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| DeMarcus Barner | LB | Southern Mississippi |
| Tony Coker | LB | Kansas |
| Dwight DeVaughn | CB | Central Oklahoma |
| Phil Hawkins | OL | Houston |
| Jesus Hidalgo | LB | Kansas |
| Cody Horton | OL | Chadron State |
| Jason Martinez | LB | Baker University |
| Jay McNeil | S | Wyoming |
| Jimmy Taylor | LB | New Mexico |
| Blake Pearson | QB | Southwest Missouri State |
| Adrian Stargell | DL | Central Missouri State |
2000 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Cliff Brye | WR | Nebraska |
| DJ Chapman | S | Lincoln University |
| Greg Cole | DE | Kansas |
| Dustin Demel | QB | Fort Hays State |
| Leo Etienne | LB | Kansas |
| Brandon Gregory | DB | New Mexico |
| Luke Harrington | TE | Fort Hays State |
| Marvin Harris | DB | Eastern Michigan |
| Brady Jones | LB | Northwest Oklahoma State |
| Daniel Kegler | DL | New Mexico |
| Matt Koster | OL | Northwestern |
| Terrance Lloyd | WR | Eastern Michigan |
| Lamont Rankin | DL | Lincoln University |
| Tank Reece | DL | Kansas State |
| Bryan Thomas | RB | Midwestern State |
1999 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Jeff Ast | DB | Southwestern College |
| Antwaun Bynum | LB | Missouri |
| Dan Bythwood | WR | Nevada |
| Rodney Burgess | DB | Nebraska |
| Rashid Hannibal | DL | Mid-America Nazarene |
| Shaun Hill | QB | Maryland |
| Tyler Klug | OL | Fort Hays State |
| Cliff Martin | DB | Kansas State |
| Rusy Miller | DL | Central Missouri State |
| Mickey Ramsey | LB | Baker University |
| Terrence Sims | DB | Oklahoma |
| Jeff Mayer | WR | Hastings College |
| Derrick Vann | WR | Kansas |
| Caleb Walker | OL | Southwest Missouri State |
1998 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Kevin Barry | OL | Arizona |
| Rashaad Bonner | DT | Upper Iowa |
| Jordan Ediger | OL | Emporia State |
| Tom Growq | TE | Robert Morris University |
| Josh Kellerman | OL | Kansas |
| Mason Linden | FB | Ottawa University |
| David Monroe | LB | Missouri |
| Jamison Palmer | RB | Middle Tennessee State |
| Nick Payne | WR | Middle Tennessee State |
| Dedrick Rhone | DB | Northern Iowa |
| Shelton Ross | DE | Arizona |
| Anthony Wadley | WR | Texas-El Paso |
| Terrell Washington | DE | Illinois |
| John Paul Lamatsch | TE | Baker University |
| Bo Waun | DE | Bethany College |
1997 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Arland Bruce | RB | Minnesota |
| Ty Cohoon | DB | Kansas |
| Terrance Floyd | OL | Minnesota |
| Donvetis Franklin | CB | Michigan State |
| Clorenzo Griffin | DB | Minnesota |
| Billy Price | LB | Bowling Green |
| Troy West | LB | Oklahoma State |
1996 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Tinker Keck | DB | Cincinnati |
1995 |
| PLAYER | POS | SCHOOL |
| Jerome Evans | DL | Kansas State |
| Jason Gamble | OL | Clemson |
| Excel Lucas | DB | Temple |
| Rich Robich | LB | Georgia |